On Sunday, Craigslist
removed the Adult Services section from its U.S. sites, replacing it with a stark black-and-white "censored" message. However, many believe that the fact that the site didn't remove the section, but instead replaced it with a message, means that the battle over Adult Services is not completely over.
As we noted before, if Craigslist really wanted to remove the section, why not just do that: remove it? Instead, by labeling it as "censored" and making it stand out so much, Craigslist looks to be making a point, that the removal of the section is more about censorship than any real attempt at halting prostitution ads.

After all, it's easy to find escort services and call girls if one just searches a little. Indeed, you can find them with a Google search, and even on that paragon of cleanliness (Steve Jobs has repeatedly said that the App Store's approval process is a way to keep porn out of the App Store, among other things), the iPhone using its Safari browser.
The Adult Services section could bring Craigslist as much as $44 million a year, annually, it's
been estimated. Meanwhile, the federal Communications Decency Act protects Web sites against liability for what their users post on the sites, so it seems that Craigslist would be protected against legal action.
Thomas R. Burke, a First Amendment lawyer at Davis Wright Tremaine who specializes in Internet law, said, “It certainly appears to be a statement about how they feel about being judged in the court of public opinion. It’s certainly the law that they’re not liable for it, but it’s another matter if the attorneys general are saying change your ways.”
Recently a large group of State Attorneys General (Arkansas, Connecticut, Idaho, Illinois, Iowa, Kansas, Maryland, Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, New Hampshire, Ohio, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas and Virginia) sent a letter to Craigslist stating that the site is not sufficiently blocking potentially illegal ads promoting prostitution and child trafficking. A number of those weighed in with statements regarding the recent "closure" of Craigslist's Adult Services.
Connecticut attorney general Richard Blumenthal: “If this announcement is a stunt or a ploy, it will only redouble our determination to pursue this issue with Craigslist, because they would be in a sense be thumbing their nose at the public interest. Raising public awareness is extraordinarily important, because it increases support for changes in the law that will hold them accountable. Their view of the law, which is blanket immunity for every site on the Internet, never has been upheld by the United States Supreme Court, and I think there is some serious doubt.”
Richard Cordray, the Ohio attorney general, said on Sunday: “We’re taking it at face value. I think it’s a step forward, maybe grudging, in response to the efforts of the attorneys general.”
Lisa Madigan, the attorney general of Illinois, took note of just how Craigslist accomplished their closure: “Certainly because of the way they did it. it leaves an open question as to whether this is truly the end of adult services on Craigslist or if this is just a continuing battle.”
To this point, Craigslist has made no official statement on the closure of the section. Only time will tell if the closure is permanent, or if the battle over Adult Services is still raging.
This story was first posted as "Is the Craigslist 'Censored' Section Just a Stunt?" at HULIQ.com, by the same author.
Recent Comments